20 Collector's Items That Are Now Worthless, Ranked In Order

Time For A Garage Sale: Collector’s Items That Aren’t Worth Keeping - Brake For It
Classic
Modern Auto
Culture
Search for:
Classic
Modern Auto
Culture
About
Contact
Copyright
Privacy
Terms
Time For A Garage Sale: Collector’s Items That Aren’t Worth Keeping
Rose Reilly | Trending | 2 Mar 2026
Collecting often begins out of love. It's exciting to acquire a new baseball card or win the bid on a rare toy. But sometimes, we hold onto collections because we think they might hold value that could pay off later. Sadly, unless it's something really rare, that's not the case with the items on this list. Keep reading to help you decide if it's time to clean out your collection.
Beanie Babies
DAVID BREWSTER/Star Tribune via Getty Images
Ty Beanie Babies are an item on this list that's hard not to collect. Once you acquire one Beanie Baby, you're compelled to find more. Kids enjoy the toys for what sets them apart from the rest -- the 'bean' stuffing rather than the typical fluff you find in plush toys.
However, in 1995, adults began collecting Beanie Babies as a financial investment, seeing the potential for high resale value. That year, the toys that were quickly flipped on eBay sold for ten times the original purchase price. But once the fad died down, so did their worth.
ADVERTISEMENT
The Majority Of Vinyl Records
ADVERTISEMENT
Robert Alexander/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT
Think vinyl records are a thing of the past? Wrong. Vinyl records are still being made today during what some are calling a "vinyl revival." In 2017, Sony Entertainment announced that it would begin pressing vinyl records again, and interest in vinyl has been increasing in the years since.
ADVERTISEMENT
With so much vinyl in the marketplace, most don't hold any true value. It's only the rare and select vintage records that will be worth anything. It's best to do your research instead of holding onto false hope that your crate of records is worth serious cash.
ADVERTISEMENT
Norman Rockwell Collector Plates
ADVERTISEMENT
GABRIEL BOUYS/AFP via Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT
Norman Rockwell is one of the greatest painters and illustrators in American history. His work graces the covers of American classics including Tom Sawyer and Huckleberry Finn. His cover illustrations for The Saturday Evening Post delighted readers for almost five decades.
ADVERTISEMENT
However, collector plates featuring Norman Rockwell illustrations should be acquired for enjoyment, not for investment. Antique Trader values the collector plates at $10 each, declining from its previous estimated value of $50-75.
ADVERTISEMENT
Pez Dispensers
ADVERTISEMENT
STORMI GREENER/Star Tribune via Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT
Some toys are worth a fortune, and others aren't. Pez dispensers are both a toy and an accessory for candy. Kids love finding their favorite cartoon characters configured into a candy dispenser. Some people even hold onto them, collecting them into adulthood.
ADVERTISEMENT
Unless you have a grand collection of Pez dispensers, each item only goes for a buck or two. Even the limited edition Elvis Presley Pez dispenser collection is valued at a low $9.20.
ADVERTISEMENT
Pandora Charms
ADVERTISEMENT
John Parra/Getty Images for Pandora
ADVERTISEMENT
First appearing in the early to mid-2000s, Pandora necklaces and bracelets became a hot trend. The pieces are designed to be layered and paired with each other, featuring fun elements of sparkle and style. Once buyers saw their favorite pieces being discontinued, their value went up.
ADVERTISEMENT
However, this is only for a few rare charms that were discontinued. Collecting all Pandora Charms as an investment isn't worth the while.
ADVERTISEMENT
Newer Star Wars Toys
ADVERTISEMENT
Craig Barritt/Getty Images for Disney
ADVERTISEMENT
Rare Star Wars toys from the 1970s have the potential to boost your bank account. Obscure Star Wars figurines like the "Yak Face," also known as "Joe Camel" can be worth thousands of dollars if you find the right buyer. Unfortunately, the same can't be said for modern Star Wars toys.
ADVERTISEMENT
You could stockpile baby Yodas and see what happens. But experts have cautioned that action figures and toys from the '90s and '00s won't hold value, so long as they're mass-produced.
ADVERTISEMENT
Royal Family Memorabilia
ADVERTISEMENT
Katie Collins/PA Images via Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT
One of the most famous families on the planet, the British royal family is beloved by the people of the Commonwealth and beyond. Exciting events like royal weddings, births, and jubilees are all a reason for celebration.
ADVERTISEMENT
With the events come plenty of memorabilia; the faces of the newlyweds plastered on mugs and buttons-- even custom dolls. This might be something you'd want to keep for memory's sake, but stocking up on royal family memorabilia won't send your kid to college. Mass-produced items like this don't have the same allure and value as something that is rare and made in small quantities.
ADVERTISEMENT
New Comic Books
ADVERTISEMENT
Education Images/Universal Images Group via Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT
Purchasing a pile of new comic books is not a wise investment. These collectibles lose their value as soon as you leave the store. Even if you keep the comics in mint condition, without any special significance, no fan will seek it out and pay more money for it later.
ADVERTISEMENT
On the other hand, comic books from the 1930s-'50s, when our favorite superheroes debuted, can pay for a mansion-- Batman's first appearance in Detective Comics banked a record $2.8 million. But the average comic won't get you far.
ADVERTISEMENT
Stamps
ADVERTISEMENT
Kurt Wittman/Education Images/Universal Images Group via Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT
Collecting stamps can be tricky and misleading. Although someone might "value" your stamp collection at a decent number, as it turns out, buyers aren't interested. Select older stamps that are in perfect condition have the potential to hold value, but it's a needle in a haystack.
ADVERTISEMENT
Stamps are mass-produced, with little chance of having any true value as a reason to hold onto them. This is hard news to take for older generations who were once informed to take good care of stamp collections, as they'd be worth money one day.
ADVERTISEMENT
Pogs
ADVERTISEMENT
Xavier ROSSI/Gamma-Rapho via Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT
If you had a family member who grew up in the '90s, it's likely they went through a Pog phase, and there are some still hiding around the house. For many, the pieces were more fun to collect and enjoy then actually playing the Pog game (yes, there is a game associated with them).
ADVERTISEMENT
And the same can be said about collecting them for monetary value -- keep them to enjoy them, not to sell. Most collections will go for $10 if someone actually offers to buy them, and individual Pogs go for $1, which is less than the cost of shipping.
ADVERTISEMENT
Antique Silverware
ADVERTISEMENT
Education Images/Universal Images Group via Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT
It's a time-honored tradition to pass along silverware and precious China from one generation to the next as a family heirloom. Silver is often presented as a housewarming gift or to a newlywed couple.
ADVERTISEMENT
Silver that holds special meaning should be held onto. If you try to sell vintage silver on eBay or other sites you'll be disappointed to see how many other listings there are for antique sets, driving down the value.
ADVERTISEMENT
Porcelain Dolls
ADVERTISEMENT
Altan Gocher / Barcroft Media / Barcroft Media via Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT
Porcelain and ceramic dolls are popular among collectors, who may view them as pleasant childhood memories. Like this photo, doll collectors go so far as to designate a full room in the house to display their dolls, as they take up more room than other collectibles.
ADVERTISEMENT
If the goal is to make money, however, that room is better used as a rental. Aside from select rare dolls, these porcelain reminders of the…

Text scraped from the landing page for research purposes. © respective owners. This text is sourced from the advertiser's public landing page; for removal, contact dmca@luba.media.